Posted in Mental Health

Hopkins Sets the Clock Back Again

Not content with womansplaining how men feel about women proposing marriage, motormouth Katie Hopkins has lashed out once more and practically declared that depression doesn’t exist. Speaking from her ivory tower, she devolved to spreading all the stereotypes about mental health following the events of the Germanwings tragedy last week.

Andreas Lubitz, the German co-pilot suspected of deliberately crashing the Germanwings flight in the Alps. Source: bbc.co.uk

As far as Hopkins is concerned, suicidal people are merely “attention seeking bastards” who should “top themselves in private”. Many people do, Katie. I know of at least two men who have taken their own lives and both did it in private.

Much can be said about the poor and stereotypical view of the mentally ill presented in the media in the wake of the tragedy, most of all about the pilot’s mental state on the day of the crash, but no clear motive has yet been determined. We know he underwent psychotherapy in the months leading up to the crash and we know he was suicidal. These facts cannot be denied. What is not clear is his mental state on the day of the crash. It has been speculated that he was pushed back to work before he was ready. Only after the investigation will we know the full facts.

troglodyte

Mental health charity Mind were quick to respond (as were the male mental health charity CALM) to media reports and we know that leaping to sensationalist conclusions is part and parcel of the media these days. Hopkins took it one step further in setting the clock back decades on the day the country was putting its clocks forward (excellent phrase from James Martin!)

She goes on to repeat ridiculous tropes about how a pair of running shoes can cure depression. Not only is this crass and offensive, it has been disproven time and time again. Exercise, fresh air, forcing a smile and a positive mentality are not cures for properly diagnosed clinical depression. The more we maintain that depressed people want to be that way, the more we reinforce stereotypes and the more we unjustly demonise people.

We know that men are far more likely to take their own lives than women: 78% and rising year on year, while the percentage and number of women decreases. We also know that it manifests itself differently in men. It will be displayed as angry outbursts, short temper, alcoholism and sometimes physical violence – even in people who are not usually violent. Usually, most depressed men are more likely to hurt themselves than somebody else which means we must take extra caution before leaping to the conclusions about this terrible crash. Murder-suicide is rare and despite sensationalist reporting, far less common than straight suicide.

Advertisements

Author:

I go by the name of Frank Speaking. My blog "In the Mind of Men" (former name Chin Up, Chest High) started out as a chronicle of my mental health recovery. Now it is a forum where I discuss issues related to male mental health.

2 thoughts on “Hopkins Sets the Clock Back Again

  1. I’ve read (in course textbook in introductory psychology) that psychotherapy is actually the best for depression. Therapy and antidepressants, if you are severely depressed. But if your depression is not severe, antidepressants work no better than a placebo. In that case, you might as well do whatever you believe in – run, do acupuncture, sacrifice an animal or whatever else, it’ll all work. Antidepressants are used so much, because it’s cheaper than several sessions of psychotherapy.

    That said, I don’t think her comments were very helpful. I understand she’s angry at that guy for taking so many people with him, but there is no need to take it out on all other depressed people.

    1. I agree, antidepressants on their own are merely papering over cracks and should always be used in conjunction with therapy. Most people I know who are on them or have been on them have worked therapy and pills in tandem.

      Exercise gives you a high but it lasts a matter of minutes after the end of a workout. It could make that person addicted to exercise – I know I came close when I had my last major bout three years ago.

      I feel her anger is misplaced. We should be taking a closer look at the employers who failed to give him adequate care and may have even pushed him back to work before he was ready. Attitudes such as Hopkins’ view that depression doesn’t exist may end up being the reason that this tragedy occurred.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s